‘Perfect storm’ behind generics price hikes, PAC hears

Latest

‘Perfect storm’ behind generics price hikes, PAC hears

In Latest

A recent Public Accounts Committee hearing was told that a “perfect storm” of events was behind the dramatic price increases on generic medicines in 2017 that were the basis of a National Audit Office investigation.

The NAO report said that medicines shortages were a contributing factor to the “unprecedented rise” in spending on generic medicines in 2017-18, with an unexpected rise in wholesaler margins cited as another potential factor.

Speaking before the PAC on July 4, Warwick Smith, director of the British Generic Manufacturers Association, said the shortages were partly due to regulatory action taken against four companies, including “two of our members who were scale manufacturers”.

This was a “perfect storm” of events such as rarely happens, Mr Smith said, adding that he “would be surprised to see this recurring quickly”.

Commenting on how shortages can sometimes come about and how different stakeholders are affected, Mr Smith said: “I think it is important we distinguish between different circumstances that lead to these occurrences… Most shortages… occur because of third party events… without any warning for manufacturers, for anyone, as much as pharmacy or patients”.

The current system whereby market competition determines generic medicine prices works well and makes drugs affordable, some witnesses claimed. Sir Chris Wormald, permanent secretary at the Department of Health and Social Care, said: “Our spend on generics in the year of fluctuations went down, not up.”

Pharmacy helped prevent patient harm

Pharmaceutical Services Negotiating Committee regional member for the North East and Cumbria, Mark Burdon, said: “I have not observed and am not hearing reports of patients going without medicines for any length of time, or indeed of patient harm. Much of that is down to the efforts of community pharmacists.”

Mr Burdon agreed with the written evidence provided by Dorset contractor Mike Hewitson, which stated that stock shortages “were sometimes caused by rumours by wholesalers that resulted in a self-fulfilling prophecy, as pharmacists ordered several months’ stock at a time.”

“Not a new problem”

Professor Karim Meeran of Imperial College’s medical education department said shortages and resulting price hikes have been “going on since about 2010 with different drugs” and are “not a new problem.”

Professor Meeran suggested that health bodies should consider whether it is viable to manufacture drugs on the World Health Organization list of essential medicines in the UK, in order to ensure a steady supply of these medicines.

“All of the drugs on that list should be very cheap to make,” Professor Meeran said. “Why don’t we make it in the UK and sell it and use the NHS as a bulk buyer rather than go through wholesalers, because the wholesalers are splitting the NHS?”

However, the BGMA’s Warwick Smith argued that this could come up against ‘commercial realities’: “Overall, the UK is a net exporter of medicines but a net importer of generic medicines, and that is simply because we cannot make them cheaply enough here to compete with prices that come out of the other markets, be they central Europe, India or China. I’m afraid that that is just the commercial reality, unless there is some public policy decision to change that.”

New powers welcomed

BGMA's Warwick Smith (parliamentlive.tv)

Anne Marie Morris MP questioned whether new measures that came into force in July that give the DHSC more power to obtain information about generics prices would be sufficient.

“Even if these new regulations make [information relating to generic medicines] available, it is limited, because it comes in blocks,” Ms Morris said, addressing the BGMA’s Warwick Smith. “Secondly, as far as I can see, to make your members divulge it, there really isn’t much of a penalty.”

Mr Smith countered: “My members, with one or two exceptions, have already been providing the data voluntarily to the Department of Health, which is how they calculate the category M tariff reimbursement price.”

Mr Smith said that while that information currently “flows four times a year,” there are provisions to make this monthly or weekly “if things are happening in the market that make that a more sensible way of behaving”.

He added: “We welcome the new powers, because they will bring into that mix companies that have not been providing the data voluntarily… I think the Department will now be able to track, almost, individual products throughout the supply chain, so they can see what is happening at the different stages. They will be able to see if product is going “missing” within the supply chain, which is important.”

Record my learning outcomes

Latest

Inspiring stories related to health, fitness and the pursuit of wellbeing

Share:

More like this

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Locate a Locum Learning launched

Locate Learning launches today, increasing members access to extensive learning library.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

MHRA issues thermometer warning

MHRA issues thermometer warning after increase in the number of unreliable products available in the UK. 

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Nearly 90 per cent of adults would have tested positive for Covid-19 antibodies in June, says ONS

ONS estimates vast majority would have had antibodies in mid-June.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

New NHS clinics to provide pelvic floor support for women

Pregnant women and new mums are to receive support from new NHS clinics.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

NICE recommends mental health support for people with acne

Mental health support is key in managing acne vulgaris, says clinical watchdog.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

RPS calls for action on women's health inequalities

Action is needed to reduce the inequalities faced by women when accessing health services, the Royal Pharmaceutical Society has said. 

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Reports of potential bidding war over LloydsPharmacy

LloydsPharmacy could be the target of a three-way bidding war fought among financial investors over the next few weeks, it has been reported.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Dukes to leave PSNC in September

PSNC chief executive Simon Dukes will leave his post at the end of September after just over three and-a-half years in the role.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

NHSE: Pharmacy must speak 'as one' to gain power

Community pharmacies need to speak 'as one' to gain greater influence within primary care, a senior NHS England official has said. 

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

E-cig loophole puts minors at risk, Government told

A charity criticises the government for failing to close a loophole allowing companies to hand out free e-cigarettes to under-18s. 

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Lloyds pulls nasal spray over 'bold' Covid claims

LloydsPharmacy has "paused" sales of a £15 nasal spray that claims to neutralise the coronavirus before it can make people ill.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

DH sets ambitious targets for winter flu programme

The Department of Health and Social Care announces that it aims to vaccinate 85 per cent of people aged 65 and over against influenza.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Wright review group to hold focus groups to form proposals

The Wright review steering group will hold a series of online focus groups and workshops this month and in August.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Two Solihull pharmacists jailed for illegal supply of POMs

Dean Dookhan and Narvinder Nandra pleaded guilty to two charges concerning the illegal supply of 21,000 Zolpidem pills.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Pharmacist to run London marathon for charity

Pharmacist Mohammed Hussain will run the London marathon to raise money for Pharmacist Support.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Boots opens flu jab bookings as demand soars

Boots says it has opened bookings for its winter flu jab service amid reports of soaring demand. 

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Running app downloaded over five million times this month

The Couch to 5K app contains advice and information from a celebrity coach to help users record their progress. 

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

Drug companies fined £260m for "excessive and unfair" price hikes to hydrocortisone tablets over a 10 year period.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

IBS sufferers worried about return to workplace

People with irritable bowel syndrome are anxious about lockdown easing and the prospect of going back to the workplace contributing to their symptoms.

1 Min Article

bookmark_icon_off
Latest

GPhC too soft on corporate multiples claims PDA

The GPhC is disproportionately tough on individual registrants compared to pharmacy owners and premises, the PDA has claimed. 

1 Min Article

Recommended Learning

bookmark icon off
Sponsored education

VIAGRA® CONNECT at the Counter

Build your confidence in advising customers with erection problems so you can help make a real difference to their lives 

2 Min Module

bookmark icon off
Sponsored education

Understanding the impact of dry skin conditions

Learn about the emotional impact of dry and eczema-prone skin, and confidently recommend products for skin treatment and maintenance.

10 Min Module

bookmark icon off
Sponsored education

Managing fever in children

Get to grips with the current guidance on managing fever in children and how antipyretics can help, and discover products you can recommend.

10 Min Module

Sponsored education

Acute diarrhoea: effective symptom management

This module busts the myths surrounding diarrhoea treatments and explores the products available OTC so you can recommend the right treatment.

10 Min Module

bookmark icon off
Sponsored education

Treating acid reflux and heartburn in the pharmacy

Understand how omeprazole 20mg works to treat heartburn and acid reflux symptoms

2 Min Module

bookmark icon off
Sponsored education

Pain conversations - making effective recommendations

Explore our detailed case studies to help understand how to advise customers on different causes of pain.

15 Min Module